✦Template Printable Ideas Insights

Understanding MLB Scouting Grades: The Comprehensive Scale Explained

By

Beneath the electrifying atmosphere of Major League Baseball (MLB) games lies the meticulous and often overlooked craft of scouting and grading players. This process isn't merely about identifying the next big star; it's a critical facet of every organization's long-term strategy. Central to this process is the MLB scouting grades scale, the secret language that scouts speak, and the key to unlocking a player's potential.

The grading scale is not público, but industry insiders have shed some light on its intricacies. It's essential to note that grades are not static and can vary based on the scout, the organization, and the specific role within the game. However, a general consensus exists among scouts about what the grades mean.

Understanding the MLB Scouting Grades Scale

The scale typically ranges from 20-80, with 50 being the baseline for an average player. Most big league players fall within the 45-70 range. Any grade above 60 indicates above-average ability, with 80 representing the zenith of human potential in the sport. Let's delve into the key grades and what they signify.

MLB Scouts Grading Scale
MLB Scouts Grading Scale
Mlb
Mlb
the baseball score book is open and ready to be used
the baseball score book is open and ready to be used

Grades 20-39: Well Below Average

Players in this range struggle at the professional level. They often lack basic fundamental skills and are typically not considered viable prospects. However, it's not uncommon for scouts to grade specific tools, like speed or power, high despite a low overall grade.

For instance, a player might have a 25 (poor) hit tool but a 60 (average) speed grade. Scouts will then mention the split in their reports, indicating they see potential in the player's speed despite his struggles at the plate. Nonetheless, these splits are exceptions rather than the rule in this range.

Baseball / Softball : Graphique 3 des Scouts en cours de match
Baseball / Softball : Graphique 3 des Scouts en cours de match
Sort Cards by Professional Baseball Teams | Card Dividers W/ FREE MLB Labels | Vertical - Etsy
Sort Cards by Professional Baseball Teams | Card Dividers W/ FREE MLB Labels | Vertical - Etsy
Lessons learned from MLB draft
Lessons learned from MLB draft

Grades 40-49: Below Average to Poor

Players in this range may have some redeemable qualities but are still far from being viable professional prospects. They might possess one tool above average, but their overall game is unrefined and often unteachable. Teams might take a chance on these players in the late stages of the amateur draft or as undrafted free agents, but expectations are low.

Scouts will often provide specific feedback about why they graded a player 40 in a particular category versus a 45. This level of detail is crucial in helping organizations decide whether to invest time and resources into developing a player.

Evaluating Specific Player Skills

Beyond the overall grade, scouts assess a player's specific skills or tools. The most common categories are hitting, power, running, throwing, and fielding, with each rated on a 20-80 scale. Here's how these grades are interpreted:

an old baseball score sheet with numbers and lines
an old baseball score sheet with numbers and lines
grades
grades
an old newspaper article about major league averages
an old newspaper article about major league averages
Charts
Charts
a table with numbers and symbols for different types of items in the computer screen shot
a table with numbers and symbols for different types of items in the computer screen shot
a baseball field with the numbers on it and other things in each area that are labeled
a baseball field with the numbers on it and other things in each area that are labeled

Hit Tool & Power

The hit tool and power are often the most scrutinized skills in the batting department. A 50 hit tool indicates an average ability to make contact and barrel up the baseball, while a 50 power grade suggests average raw strength. A 60 grade in either category suggests well above-average ability, with 70 indicating elite levels.

iterative improvement in these areas can greatly impact a player's stock. For instance, a scout might note that a player went from a 45 hit tool to a 55, indicating significant growth in their ability to make contact.

Speed, Arm Strength & Fielding

Speed (running) and arm strength are crucial for outfielders and middle infielders. A 50 grade in either category suggests average speed or arm strength, while a 60 indicates elite status. Fielding ability is also critical, particularly for infielders and catchers. A 50 grade suggests an average defender, while a 60 or higher indicates elite glove work.

ad eBay - $1.99 - 2000 APBA MLB Premiere Edition Sean The Mayor Casey - Seller: 99.9% - Ungraded - T
ad eBay - $1.99 - 2000 APBA MLB Premiere Edition Sean The Mayor Casey - Seller: 99.9% - Ungraded - T
Major League Baseball Player Salaries 2003 to 2023 | Data Visualization | Tableau | Dashboard
Major League Baseball Player Salaries 2003 to 2023 | Data Visualization | Tableau | Dashboard
just tap your head bro
just tap your head bro

Scouts often geography these grades relative to a player's position. For example, a shortstop might earn a 55 fielding grade due to their demanding position, while a first baseman with the same defensive ability might receive a 45.

Pitching Evaluations

Pitchers are graded based on their fastball velocity (in MPH) and their off-speed nastiness. A fastball in the mid-90s tends to receive an 80 grade, while a low-90s heater hovers around 70. Breaking balls, sliders, and changeups are graded on a 20-80 scale. Command, often the most critical pitching tool, is also assessed and can make or break a pitcher's prospects.

Pitchers with multiple plus pitches (70 or higher) and excellent command have the highest ceilings, while those lacking velocity or control may be destined for bullpen roles or lower minor leagues.

Scouting has long been the heartbeat of baseball operations. It's more than just assigning numbers to players; it's a sophisticated, intricate process that requires nuance, expertise, and frequently, intuition. As teams continue to rely more heavily on data, the human element of scouting remains indispensable. After all, a player's grade is only as good as the scout who assigned it, and the organization that developed the talent.