In the captivating world of Major League Baseball (MLB), the process of evaluating players extends far beyond the box score. Scouting grades, a cryptic yet crucial aspect of player evaluation, provide insight into a player's potential at the MLB level. These grades, an exclusive language of baseball insiders, translate a player's skills into a simple, scalable, and universally understandable format. But what do these grades mean, and how can a fan decipher the code?
At its core, the MLB scouting scale is a 20-80 grading system, with 50 representing an average MLB player. This scale allows evaluators to pinpoint a player's strengths and weaknesses, predicting their future success and providing a roadmap for development. But to truly grasp the meaning behind these grades, one must delve into the nuances of each category.
Understanding the 20-80 Scouting Scale
The 20-80 scouting scale is a sanity checker for scouts, standardizing their evaluations and ensuring a common language across organizations. While some grades might appear objective, such as throwing velocity, others, like hit tool, are more subjective and reflect the evaluator's personal opinion. However, understanding the scale's parameters is key to interpreting these grades.
Grades of 50 are considered MLB average, with 40 a borderline MLB tool, and 30 a deep minor league skill. Conversely, a 60 grade suggests an above-average MLB tool, 70 a plus tool, and 80 a superstar, elite-level skill. On the other end, a grade of 20 indicates a skill on or close to the fringes of professional baseball.
Physical Projections and Tools
Physical attributes – like speed, power, and throwing velocity – are typically the easiest skills for evaluators to grade. These 'tools' provide a snapshot of a player's athletic ability and, in combination with other factors, can suggest whether they will be an asset on the basepaths, in the field, or at the plate.
For instance, a running back with elite (80) speed will likely be a threat on the Hagen strip. Similarly, a high school catcher with power potential (70 raw power) could project as a destructive middle-of-the-order bat at the major league level. However, these physical attributes must be paired with baseball skills to translate to on-field success.
Evaluating Baseball Skills
Baseball skills – like hitting, fielding, and pitching – are more nuanced. These categories assess a player's ability to perform the fundamental aspects of the game, with higher grades indicating mastery. For example, an elite contact hitter (80 hit tool) would have exceptional hand-eye coordination, plate coverage, and the ability to make consistent contact with a wide variety of pitches.
Conversely, a mid-60s fielding grade denotes above-average actions, instincts, and range, but also suggests the player might lack elite reflexes or hands. Evaluators must weigh these skill grades alongside the tangible physical attributes to project a player's potential at the MLB level.
Interpreting Each Grade
While the 20-80 scale provides a reliable framework for evaluation, uncovering the meaning behind specific grades requires considerably more context. For instance, a high-grade fastball with little movement (55 grade) is drastically different from a mid-grade fastball with premium cutter-like action (60 grade).
This section will explore what each grade generally signifies, addressing the common misconceptions and providing clarity on certain nuances of the 20-80 scoring system.
Grades in the 20s and 30s
At the bottom of the spectrum, grades in the 20s and 30s are infrequent and typically indicative of organizational depth rather than potential stars. These grades can, however, unearth diamonds in the rough. A late-round draft pick with a 25-grade hit tool and 40-grade power might not light up a scoreboard, but he may possess other desirable traits, such as elite defense or high contact rates, making him an intriguing gamble.
Moreover, skillset and situation matter. A low-grade (30) raw power might translate to well above-average game power if paired with strong plate discipline and a launch angle-oriented approach. This illustrates the fallacy of evaluating players using grades in isolation.
Grades in the 40s and 50s
In the 40s and 50s, players possess marginal or fringy major league skills. Organizations invest heavily in these players, fostering development and hoping for a breakthrough. While most lack an elite tool, they might possess multiple grades in the 45-55 range, suggesting future average-to-above-average MLB contributor potential.
A college pitcher may showcase a solid fastball (50 grade) and fringe curveball (45 grade) but lack a reliable third pitch. Despite these drawbacks, his college performance and projectable frame could make him an intriguing late-round pick.
Grades in the 60s and 70s
The 60s and 70s constitute the building blocks of elite prospects. A grade of 60 denotes an above-average MLB tool, while 70 signifies a plus skill, bucking the average. These prospects typically possess at least two above-average tools and one elite tool, giving scouts cause for excitement.
A high school outfielder with 80-grade speed and 65-grade power might not have an elite hit tool (55) but projects as a dynamic, game-changing player at the major league level due to his athleticism. This example illustrates another crucial aspect of the 20-80 scale: while elite tools capture the imagination, well-rounded prospects are most likely to reach their potential.
Grades in the 80s and Beyond
Reaching the 80-grade threshold is an incredibly rare feat, reserved for superstar-elite talents. These players exhibit near-unparalleled skills, providing a seemingly limitless ceiling. Keep in mind, however, that topping the 80 threshold does not guarantee superstardom. History provides several examples of 'can't miss' prospects who never panned out.
The 80-grade Rain Man, Mike Trout, stands as the poster child for the 20-80 scale, demonstrating how prodigious physical attributes, combined with an ingrained understanding of the game, can translate to unprecedented success.
In summary, understanding MLB scouting grades requires a keen appreciation for nuance and context. This article has scratched the surface, providing fans with a basic understanding of the 20-80 scale and its intricacies. The next time you hear a scout speak, armed with this knowledge, you can delve deeper into the captivating world of player development and evaluation.