✦Template Printable Ideas Insights

MLB Scouting Grades: A Comprehensive Guide

By

Major League Baseball (MLB) scouting, the process of evaluating and grading prospects, is a critical aspect of team building. Scouting grades are used to objectively assess a player's skills and project their future potential. But what do these grades mean, and how are they calculated? Let's dive into the complex world of MLB scouting grades.

At its core, MLB scouting is about identifying future major league talent. Scouts assign grades to a player's tools - hitting, power, speed, arm strength, fielding, and more - on a 20-80 scale, where 50 is considered average big league production. These grades are then used to project a player's future value.

Understanding the 20-80 Scouting Scale

The 20-80 scale might seem arbitrary, but it's widely used because it provides a standardized framework for evaluating players. It's based on the idea that a '70' tool is roughly an average major league tool, with each 10-point increase representing a significant jump in ability.

an image of the mlb team logos and their respective name on twitter, which is also in
an image of the mlb team logos and their respective name on twitter, which is also in
Lessons learned from MLB draft
Lessons learned from MLB draft
Mlb
Mlb

Here's a simple breakdown:

  • 20-30: Well below average (e.g., a 20-grade hitting prospect can barely make contact)
  • 40-50: Below to well below average (e.g., a 40-grade power prospect has some raw pop but can't consistently drive the ball)
  • 50: Average
  • 55-60: Above average (e.g., a 60-grade speed prospect is a legitimate burner)
  • 65-70: Well above average (e.g., a 70-grade arm strength prospect has elite arm strength)
  • 75-80: Elite (e.g., a 80-grade hitting prospect is a future Hall of Famer)

lys of Tools Evaluated

Scouts evaluate eight main tools: hitting, power, speed, arm strength, fielding, contact, discipline, and closer mentality. Hitting, power, and speed are often referred to as 'physical tools,' while contact, discipline, and closer mentality are 'bat control' tools.

the mlb best players by position
the mlb best players by position
an illustrated poster with many different baseball players and numbers on it, including the names of their respective teams
an illustrated poster with many different baseball players and numbers on it, including the names of their respective teams
Baseball / Softball: In-Game Scout Chart 1
Baseball / Softball: In-Game Scout Chart 1

Fielding and arm strength are defensive tools, with additional grades assigned for positional value. For example, a shortstop is typically expected to have better range and arm strength than a first baseman.

The Importance of Grades in Projecting Potential

Scouting grades aren't just about evaluating current ability; they're about projecting future potential. A prospect with '55' raw power might not hit many home runs in rookie ball, but if he has the track record and swing mechanics to indicate he'll grow into that power, scouts will give him a higher grade.

This is where experience and scouting intuition come into play. A great scout can watch a player take 50 swings and understand what his bat looks like at its best, even if the player isn't consistently performing at that level.

History of Baseball | Worksheet | Education.com
History of Baseball | Worksheet | Education.com
Major League Baseball (MLB) Breakdown_ How It Works, Iconic Games & Legendary Players
Major League Baseball (MLB) Breakdown_ How It Works, Iconic Games & Legendary Players
What type of miraculous fan are you? (HAPPY 7K TAKERS!)
What type of miraculous fan are you? (HAPPY 7K TAKERS!)
Baseball / Softball: In-Game Scout Chart 3
Baseball / Softball: In-Game Scout Chart 3
an info sheet with instructions on how to play the shift in different positions and positions
an info sheet with instructions on how to play the shift in different positions and positions
the baseball score sheet for each team's home base ball game, with their numbers and positions
the baseball score sheet for each team's home base ball game, with their numbers and positions

The Role of 'Ceiling' and 'Floor' in Scouting Grades

When evaluating prospects, scouts consider both the player's 'ceiling' (their maximum potential) and 'floor' (their lowest realistic outcome). A prospect with a high ceiling (e.g., a chance to be an All-Star) is more valuable than one with a low ceiling, even if their floor is similar (e.g., both are likely to reach the majors but one is much more likely to be a star).

This is why prospects with high-risk profiles (e.g., those who struggle to make contact but have massive raw power) often excite scouts. While such prospects have a low floor, their high ceiling makes them extremely valuable if they can develop their skills.

Ceiling and Floor Examples

Let's consider two hypothetical prospects - A and B. Both are hitting prospects.

Red-Hot Red Sox Offense Making Up for Run Prevention WoesBrian Fluharty-USA TODAY Sports Like...
Red-Hot Red Sox Offense Making Up for Run Prevention WoesBrian Fluharty-USA TODAY Sports Like...
a baseball player holding a bat in front of a poster with the number 3500 hit club
a baseball player holding a bat in front of a poster with the number 3500 hit club
Beginner Baseball Rules Poster | Pastel Sports Infographic (Digital Download)
Beginner Baseball Rules Poster | Pastel Sports Infographic (Digital Download)
  • Prospect A: 50 hit, 45 power, 55 speed. Ceiling: 70 hit, 60 power, 60 speed (A could be a plus hitter with above-average speed if everything clicks, but might struggle to translate his power into game power)
  • Prospect B: 35 hit, 60 power, 30 speed. Ceiling: 60 hit, 70 power, 50 speed (B has a much lower floor due to his hit grade, but if he can make enough contact, he could be a legitimate power threat with average speed)

The risk/reward dynamic between these two prospects is clear. While Prospect B's floor is much lower, his ceiling is significantly higher than Prospect A's.

In the end, MLB scouting grades are about more than just numbers. They're about reading between the lines, understanding the game, and ultimately, predicting how a player will perform in the future. It's a complex craft that combines art, science, and intuition, all in the pursuit of uncovering the next great baseball talent.