✦Template Printable Ideas Insights

MLB Scouting Grades 2023: Must-Know Prospects and Updates

By

As the 2023 MLB season approaches, fans and analysts alike are eager to dive into the latest scouting reports and player grades. These grades serve as crucial metrics, helping teams make informed decisions during the draft, trades, and free agency. Let's delve into the key aspects of MLB scouting grades for the upcoming season.

The evaluation process involves a multitude of factors, including a player's tools, skills, performance metrics, and future potential. Scouting grades are typically scored on a 20-80 scale, with 50 representing an average MLB player. Here, we'll break down the most important aspects, from hitting and pitching to fielding and baserunning.

The Art of Hitting Evaluation

Hitting grades often focus on a player's contact ability, power, and plate discipline. Understanding each component is key to assessing a hitter's potential impact at the major league level.

an image of the mlb team logos and their respective name on twitter, which is also in
an image of the mlb team logos and their respective name on twitter, which is also in
2025 all mlb second team!
2025 all mlb second team!
How MLB Scouting Departments Grade The 2023 Draft Class
How MLB Scouting Departments Grade The 2023 Draft Class

Contact (20-80 scale): This measures a hitter's ability to make consistent contact, with 50 being average. Elite contact hitters (70+) rarely strike out, while those in the 40-45 range struggle to make consistent contact.

Contact Quality and Exit Velocity

Ball exit velocity (BEV) has become an essential metric in evaluating contact quality. Batters with higher exit velocities typically hit for more power and have a better chance of driving the ball through the air and into the gaps.

the baseball player is getting ready to hit the ball with his bat in this poster
the baseball player is getting ready to hit the ball with his bat in this poster
the top 10 biggest contacts in mlb history
the top 10 biggest contacts in mlb history
the top 20 mlb career bj leaders are shown in this page, which includes information
the top 20 mlb career bj leaders are shown in this page, which includes information

Exit velocity pairs well with launch angle to create an effective batted ball profile. For example, a batter with a 95 MPH exit velocity and a 20-degree launch angle is more likely to hit a fly ball into the outfield than a line drive up the middle.

Power Against Plate Disciplne

Power (20-80 scale): This grade reflects a hitter's raw strength and ability to drive the ball with authority. While some power hitters make contact at a high rate, others sacrifice contact for the chance at a home run.

Plate discipline (20-80 scale): This measures a hitter's ability to discern balls from strikes and make adjustments during at-bats. Elite plate discipline (70+) signals a hitter's ability to work counts and capitalize on pitcher mistakes, while poor plate discipline (40-45) indicates swinging at pitches out of the strike zone.

What Happens At The 2023 MLB General Managers Meeting?
What Happens At The 2023 MLB General Managers Meeting?
mlb scouting grades 2023
mlb scouting grades 2023
a baseball player holding a bat in front of a blue and yellow background with the names of his team
a baseball player holding a bat in front of a blue and yellow background with the names of his team
2025 national league silver slugger nominees!
2025 national league silver slugger nominees!
a baseball player holding a bat on top of a field in front of a crowd
a baseball player holding a bat on top of a field in front of a crowd
an advertisement for the mlb teams in the 500 club
an advertisement for the mlb teams in the 500 club

Pitching: Velocity, Command, and More

For pitchers, the focus is on velo, secondary pitches, command, and overall repertoire. These factors contribute to a pitcher's potential effectiveness at the major league level.

Velocity (20-80 scale): Velocity is king, especially in today's game. Pitchers with elite velo (70+) often command attention and hefty price tags. However, raw velocity alone doesn't guarantee success.

The Role of Secondary Pitches

Secondary pitches (20-80 scale): A pitcher's arsenal expands beyond raw velocity. Standout offspeed pitches like sliders, curveballs, or changeups can complement a fastball, make a hitter's eye dance, and elevate a pitcher's grade.

three baseball players are shown in this screenshot
three baseball players are shown in this screenshot
the last w's appearance for every mlb team
the last w's appearance for every mlb team

Command (20-80 scale): Command is a pitcher's ability to locate pitches within the strike zone and manipulate hitters with precision. Elite command (65+) suggests a pitcher can consistently paint the corners and limit walks, while poor command (40-45) indicates diffuse control and an inability to throw strikes.

The Importance of Pitch Sequences and Repertoire

Repertoire (20-80 scale): Understanding a pitcher's sequence and mix of pitches is crucial to evaluating their potential success. Pitchers with a diverse repertoire (65+) can keep hitters off-balance, while those with a limited arsenal (40-45) may struggle to retire major league hitters.

Pitch sequencing involves the strategic order in which a pitcher throws his pitches. Knowing when to use a changeup or slider can generate swings and misses, baffle hitters, and ultimately lead to outs.

The Underrated Art of Fielding and Baserunning

Defensive and baserunning metrics impact a player's overall grade and potential role on a major league team. Whilethey can be more difficult to quantify, they remain essential to the evaluation process.

Fielding (20-80 scale): A player's fielding grade reflects their ability to make smooth and accurate throws, catch fly and ground balls, and avoid costly errors. Elite defenders (70+) at premium positions enhance a team's chances of winning, while those with poor fielding ability (40-45) create liabilities on the basepaths and in the field.

Baserunning Agility and Instincts

Baserunning (20-80 scale): Efficient and aggressive baserunning can create havoc on the basepaths. Elite baserunners (70+) can steal bases, take extra bags, and force errors, while those with subpar baserunning skills (40-45) hinder their team's chances of scoring runs.

Instincts and mental makeup remain difficult to quantify but play a significant role in overall player evaluation. Prospects with high baseball IQs, competitive drive, and a mature approach to the game often translate to professional success.

As the 2023 MLB season draws near, scouting grades offer a glimpse into the future of the game. They provide a framework for understanding a player's potential contributions and inform front offices' critical decision-making processes. With a well-rounded evaluation approach, teams can assemble rosters capable of competing at the highest level. The excitement of a new season and the promise it holds for young and veteran players alike is a testament to the enduring appeal of America's pastime. As we look ahead, may the best teams with the shrewdest scouting departments emerge victorious in the pursuit of a World Series title.