On September 12, 2016, Apple unveiled the iPhone 7 and 7 Plus, two smartphones that heralded several significant changes, including the exclusion of the popular 3D Touch feature from their lower-priced counterparts. This move surprised many, given the rave reviews the feature had initially received. So, why did Apple "kill" 3D Touch, and what does this mean for the future of iPhone technology?
3D Touch was introduced in 2015 with the iPhone 6s and 6s Plus, offering users a new, pressure-sensitive interaction with their devices. It allowed for more complex gestures, reverberating taps, and additional contextual information. However, its exclusion from the iPhone SE (2020) and the unfortunate fate of the iPhone XR (which didn't receive the improved 3D Touch of the iPhone X and XS series) begged the question: was 3D Touch a flash in the pan or a truly innovative technology?
The Underappreciated Feature
To understand why Apple killed 3D Touch, we must first explore why it wasn't embraced as expected. Despite its potential, 3D Touch fell short in seamlessly integrating into users' everyday experience. In many cases, the feature felt gimmicky, adding unnecessary steps to common tasks.
A case in point is the Peek and Pop feature, which enabled users to preview content by pressing lightly and opening it fully with a harder press. This required tremendous precision and patience, making it more annoying than convenient for many users.
Lack of Developer Adoption
One of the primary reasons behind 3D Touch's demise is the lack of developer support. App developers were slow to adopt the feature, either due to the complexity of implementation or the relatively small user base using it. Without widespread adoption, users felt that 3D Touch didn't deliver on its promise, further stunting its growth.
In contrast, look at Haptic Touch, the feature that replaced 3D Touch. It requires a simple, sustained press, making it more intuitive and accessible. Consequently, more developers are integrating it into their apps, fostering a positivity loop that 3D Touch never quite achieved.
The Haptic Touch Alternative
Apple introduced Haptic Touch in the iPhone XR, justifying its absence from lower-end models with the assertion that it was a more inclusive feature, usable by a broader range of customers. This attitude shift suggests that Apple may have decided that 3D Touch was a niche feature, catering only to a small segment of users.
By introducing Haptic Touch, Apple created a feature that was more intuitive, more inclusive, and, most importantly, readily adoptable by app developers. This change in strategy may have inadvertently sealed 3D Touch's fate.
Technological Obsolescence
Another possible reason for Apple's decision to phase out 3D Touch is technological advancements. The initially promising force touch technology may have been overshadowed by other, more practical innovations, such as Face ID and the edge-to-edge displays on newer models.
The integration of these technologies into iPhones may have been the driving factor behind the exclusion of 3D Touch from lower-priced models, suggesting that Apple may have decided to prioritize other features for the sake of cost-effectiveness and technological relevance.
Cost and Production Challenges
Manufacturing 3D Touch involved complex and expensive components, including a pressure sensor and associated hardware. These added to the production cost of the phone, making it less attractive for integration into lower-end models. In contrast, Haptic Touch can be realized with just a longer tap on the screen, making it a more cost-effective solution.
Moreover, the production challenges of 3D Touch may have been exacerbating its exclusion. In 2018, Apple's suppliers reportedly struggled to meet the production targets for the iPhone X, XS, and XS Max due to issues with 3D Touch modules.
User Perception and Feedback
Despite its initial promise, user feedback on 3D Touch was overwhelmingly negative. Many users found it difficult to use and indecisive. Worse still, users often mistakenly performed 3D Touch gestures when they didn't intend to, leading to unintended outcomes. This inconsistency and lack of user-friendliness likely contributed to Apple's decision to kill 3D Touch.
The misplaced taps and accidental pressure often associated with 3D Touch may have hinged on its user interface. While Apple and developers tried to make the gestures more intuitive, many users still struggled with them, leading Apple to question whether 3D Touch was worth the effort.
In the end, Apple's decision to kill 3D Touch was a strategic move, driven by a combination of lackluster user reception, slow developer adoption, cost, and technological advancements that made it obsolete. While it's always disheartening to see innovative features fall by the wayside, it's also a testament to Apple's ability to evolve and adapt to the changing landscape of technology and user needs. As we look to the future, it's exciting to consider what new, intuitive, and user-friendly features Apple might introduce next.