Guardianship and enduring guardianship are two legal arrangements that help protect and make decisions for individuals who, due to age, disability, or other reasons, cannot make decisions for themselves. These arrangements are crucial for ensuring the well-being and quality of life of these individuals. However, they differ in terms of the scope of authority, duration, and the decision-making process. Let's delve into the uniqueness of each and explore the differences between guardianship and enduring guardianship.
First and foremost, it's essential to understand that both guardianship and enduring guardianship provide a legal framework for someone else (the guardian) to make decisions on behalf of another person (the ward). However, the key difference lies in the extent of decisions the guardian can make and for how long.
Guardianship: A Comprehensive peroid of Care
Guardianship offers the broadest reach of decision-making power. It can encompass all aspects of an individual's life, from personal care and medical decisions to financial and legal matters.
Guardianship is often granted for a more extended period, often indefinitely. Once appointed, a guardian can make decisions as long as the individual is incapacitated or unable to make decisions independently.
Guardianship of Property and Person
Guardianship can be of the person, the property, or both. A guardian of the person makes decisions related to the individual's well-being, such as medical care, living arrangements, and social activities. A guardian of the property manages the individual's financial affairs, including income, investments, and expenses.
In some cases, a single person can act as both guardian of the person and property. Alternatively, different individuals may be appointed to these roles based on the specific needs and best interests of the ward.
Appointment and Review of Guardians
The process of appointing a guardian involves a judicial hearing where evidence is presented about the individual's incapacity and the need for a guardian. The court appoints a suitable person for the role, considering factors such as the individual's wishes, family relationships, and the person's qualifications.
Courts also periodically review guardianships to ensure they remain necessary and that the guardian is acting in the ward's best interests. This review helps protect the individual's rights and ensures the guardianship remains a meaningful and beneficial arrangement.
Enduring Guardianship: Flexibility and Pre-selection of Decision Maker
Enduring guardianship, on the other hand, is a less intrusive and more flexible arrangement. It allows an individual (the principal) to select someone they trust (the enduring guardian) to make decisions about their personal and health matters before they become incapacitated.
Enduring guardianship only comes into effect if and when the principal is found to lack the mental capacity to make decisions for themselves. It cease to be active once the principal regains their mental capacity.
Choosing an Enduring Guardian
An enduring guardian is usually appointed through an enduring guardianship appointment, a document that outlines the principal's wishes and the authority given to the enduring guardian. This document must be witnessed by an independent person and filed with the appropriate authority in the principal's jurisdiction.
A principal can revoke or modify an enduring guardianship appointment as long as they have the mental capacity to do so. This flexibility is a significant advantage of enduring guardianship over guardianship.
Limited Scope of Enduring Guardianship
While enduring guardians can make personal and health-related decisions, they cannot make financial decisions on behalf of the principal. Therefore, to cover all aspects of an individual's life, it's common to set up an enduring power of attorney alongside an enduring guardianship appointment.
An enduring power of attorney allows the principal to appoint someone to make financial and legal decisions when they lack the mental capacity to do so. This way, all aspects of an individual's life are covered with a minimum of two documents - an enduring power of attorney and an enduring guardianship appointment.
In conclusion, while both guardianship and enduring guardianship serve the same core purpose of aiding and protecting individuals who cannot make decisions for themselves, they differ in their scope, the duration they cover, and the decision-making process. Each has its place in the legal landscape and should be considered based on the individual's unique needs and circumstances. It's crucial to seek professional legal advice when deciding between these arrangements to ensure the best possible outcome and peace of mind for all involved.