If you're a veteran, you might already know about VA disability claims. However, the process can get more complex when you're considering a secondary claim. But don't worry, we're here to demystify the process with real-life examples. Let's dive in.
First, let's understand what a secondary claim is. A secondary claim is a condition or injury that occurs or gets worse due to a service-connected disability. The VA considers these secondary conditions directly related to your service, possibly making you eligible for additional compensation. Now, let's look at some examples.
Examples of Secondary Claims
To illustrate secondary claims, let's consider two veterans, John and Maria.
John served as a Marine and was awarded a 50% disability rating for a service-connected knee injury. A few years later, John started experiencing chronic back pain. His doctor determined that the constant strain on his back from adapting his walking style to accommodate his injured knee was the cause. John filed a secondary claim for his back condition, which was granted because it was directly related to his service-connected knee injury.
Lower Back Pain as a Secondary Condition
The VA often grants secondary claims for lower back pain when it's caused by the vet compensation the veteran uses for a service-connected leg injury. The veteran's altered gait places additional strain on the back, leading to back issues over time.
A VA rater might approve such a claim at a 10% rating, like they did for John, but it depends on the severity. It's crucial to have medical evidence linking your lower back pain to your service-connected leg injury.
Osteoarthritis as a Secondary Condition
Maria served in the Army and now has a 70% rating for service-connected left elbow dégénérescance (wear and tear) due to years of heavy lifting during her service. Now, she's noticing pain and stiffness in her left wrist. Her doctor suspects that the wrist issue is a result of overcompensation for her injured elbow, causing additional strain on her wrist.
Maria can file a secondary claim for her wrist condition. The VA may grant it, especially if there's medical evidence showing that Maria's wrist condition is directly related to her service-connected elbow injury.
How the VA Evaluates Secondary Claims
Now that we've seen examples, let's discuss how the VA evaluates secondary claims.
The VA uses the "direct causation" standard to decide if a condition is secondary. This means they look for a direct cause and effect relationship between the service-connected disability and the secondary condition. Medical evidence, such as doctor's reports, is crucial in proving this link.
Medical Evidence for Secondary Claims
To support your secondary claim, you'll need to prove that your secondary condition is directly due to your service-connected disability. This typically involves getting statements from your healthcare providers explaining the relationship between the two conditions.
For example, Maria's doctor could write a statement explaining how her service-connected elbow dégénérescance led to overcompensation by her wrist, causing her wrist condition. This kind of evidence can significantly strengthen your secondary claim.
Proving Direct Causation
While direct causation is the primary standard, the VA can also grant secondary claims using the "legal relationship" standard. This applies when the service-connected disability and the secondary condition have a clear, well-established connection in the medical community, even if there's not a direct cause and effect relationship.
An example is how skin cancer can be a secondary condition to service-connected exposure to atomic radiation. The VA acknowledges the well-established link between radiation exposure and skin cancer,granted as a secondary condition, even without a direct cause and effect.
Remember, every veteran's situation is unique. It's essential to consult with a veterans' advocate or a legal professional when considering a secondary claim. They can help navigate the complexities of your specific situation and optimize your chances of success.