Divorce is never an easy process, and when couples cannot agree on key issues, a contested divorce may be inevitable. Understanding the types of contested divorces can help you navigate this challenging time and make informed decisions. This article explores the different types of contested divorces, their characteristics, and potential outcomes.
A contested divorce is one in which the spouses cannot agree on one or more issues, such as property division, child custody, or spousal support. The divorce process then involves litigation, where a judge makes the final decisions based on the evidence presented. Compared to an uncontested divorce, which is faster and less expensive, contested divorces can be lengthy, costly, and emotionally taxing.
Fault-Based Contested Divorces
In some states, the reason for the divorce, or "grounds," can impact the outcome of property division and support payments. These are known as fault-based contested divorces.
A fault-based divorce means one spouse is claiming that the other is at fault for the breakdown of the marriage. Common grounds for fault include adultery, abuse, abandonment, or substance abuse. To establish fault, the accusing spouse must prove that the other spouse's actions directly led to the divorce. This often requires evidence, such as text messages, emails, or witness testimony.
Advantages of Fault-Based Divorces
Proving fault can give one spouse an advantage in the divorce, potentially leading to a larger share of marital property or greater spousal support. However, this comes with the risk of increased emotional strain and higher legal fees due to the complexity of proving fault.
For instance, if one spouse can prove the other’s infidelity, they might receive a larger portion of the marital assets or greater alimony. However, the emotional toll of exposing such sensitive information can be significant.
Disadvantages of Fault-Based Divorces
The process of assigning blame can foster animosity and bitterness, making it more difficult for the couple to communicate and cooperate in the future, particularly if they have children together. Additionally, the discovery process involved in gathering evidence can be time-consuming and expensive.
Moreover, proving fault can backfire. If the judge finds that both spouses are at fault, neither might receive a significant advantage. In some states, the concept of "comparative rectitude" means the spouse with lesser fault may receive more favorable terms.
No-Fault Contested Divorces
In contrast to fault-based divorces, no-fault divorces do not require either spouse to prove the other’s wrongdoing. Instead, the spouse seeking the divorce simply needs to claim that the marriage is irretrievably broken or that the couple has irreconcilable differences.
No-fault divorces are available in all 50 states, reflecting a shift in societal attitudes towards divorce. They aim to reduce animosity andquicker, less expensive divorces, but they can still become contested if spouses disagree on other issues.
Property Division in No-Fault Divorces
In a no-fault divorce, property division is typically based on principles of equity and fairness, rather than fault. This means that each spouse should receive a fair share of the marital property, regardless of who is at fault for the divorce. However, the specific division of property can still be contested if the spouses cannot agree on its value or division.
For example, if a couple cannot agree on who gets the marital home, they may need to hire appraisers, real estate agents, or attorneys to help negotiate or litigate this issue. The judge may ultimately decide the home's value and award it to one spouse, order it sold, or divide its value between the spouses.
Child Custody and Support in No-Fault Divorces
In no-fault divorces, child custody and support decisions are based on the best interests of the child, not the marital misconduct of the parents. This means that a spouse's infidelity or other wrongdoing does not affect their parenting time or child support obligations.
However, if a spouse’s actions have negatively impacted the child, such as in cases of abuse or neglect, the court may consider that behavior in making custody decisions. For instance, a parent who has been physically abusive may have limited or supervised visitation rights.
Contested divorces can be complex and emotionally challenging. If you find yourself in this situation, it's crucial to consult with a qualified divorce attorney who can help you understand your rights, navigate the legal system, and work towards a fair and reasonable outcome. Look for a lawyer with experience in contested divorces and a solid understanding of the laws in your state. Remember, while divorce is never easy, understanding the process and seeking competent legal representation can help you navigate this difficult time with greater confidence and assurance.