The phrase "signed above or below sincerely" is often seen in professional correspondence, but its meaning is not as straightforward as it seems. It's a peculiar way to end a letter or email, and understanding it requires a dab of historical context and a sprinkle of semantics.
In simpler times, correspondence involved physical letters written on paper. These were often signed, not just with a signature, but also with a polite closing phrase. One such phrase was "Yours sincerely", which was typically followed by the writer's name. However, the placement of this phrase presented a conundrum: should it be written above or below the signature? This is where the phrase "signed above or below sincerely" comes into play.
The Historical Context
The question of where to place "Yours sincerely" has been debated for centuries. In the 19th century, it was common to place it above the signature. However, some etiquette guides of the time also suggested placing it below, arguing that it was more polite to do so.
Over time, practice varied. Some writers preferred to keep the phrase above their signature, while others moved it below. This variation led to the coining of the phrase "signed above or below sincerely" as a way to acknowledge and accommodate this diversity in practice.
Above the Signature
Placing "Yours sincerely" above the signature can be traced back to an old tradition where writers would use the phrase "faithfully yours". Over time, "faithfully" was dropped, leaving just "Yours sincerely". Some argue that this placement makes the phrase a part of the body of the letter, rather than a separate closing.
Moreover, from a typographical standpoint, placing "Yours sincerely" above the signature can help balance the page, especially when the signature is long.
Below the Signature
The practice of placing "Yours sincerely" below the signature gained traction in the 20th century. Advocates of this style argue that it separates the closing phrase from the body of the letter, making the structure clearer.
From a practical perspective, placing the closing phrase below the signature allows for more flexibility in font sizes. If the closing is placed above the signature, the size of the closing may be dictated by the signature's size to maintain a balanced look.
The Modern Interpretation
In the digital age, the debate has largely shifted online. While some people still prefer one placement over the other, many practitioners now concede that both styles are acceptable. Some even argue that the placement doesn't matter as much as the intent behind the phrase - a polite way to end a letter.
On the other hand, some digital platforms and email client software have made the decision for us. For instance, Gmail places the closing automatically below the signature, aligning with the modern practice.
The Impact of Digital Communication
The shift to digital communication has indeed changed the dynamics of this debate. While the placement of "Yours sincerely" remains a topic of discussion, it's no longer the defining feature of a letter. Other elements, like the brevity and directness of digital communication, have taken center stage.
However, the shift doesn't mean that the old debates are irrelevant. They serve as a reminder of the rich history and evolving nature of communication. Moreover, understanding the context behind such phrases can enrich our communication, even in the digital age.
In conclusion, the phrase "signed above or below sincerely" is more than just a way to end a letter. It's a testament to the evolution of communication, from paper letters to digital correspondence. Whether you place the closing above or below your signature, what matters most is clear communication and politeness - the very essence of a sincere ending.