✦Template Printable Ideas Insights

Harry Potter and the Cursed Child: Book or Hoax?

By

Ever since the finale of the "Harry Potter" series, fans have clamored for more from J.K. Rowling's magical universe. In 2016, their wishes were partially granted with the release of "Harry Potter and the Cursed Child," a play penned by Jack Thorne in collaboration with Rowling and John Tiffany. But is thisinstallment truly a part of the Harry Potter series, or just a fan-dream come true?

The Cursed Child, set nineteen years after the events of "Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows," follows Harry's son Albus during his time at Hogwarts. It explores themes of father-son relationships, prejudice, and the power of time. While it maintains the core elements of the Potterverse, many fans and critics have debated its canonicity due to its different format and authorship.

The Controversy Around the Cursed Child

The play's origin as a stage production, instead of a novel, has sparked debate about its status in the Harry Potter series.

Harry Potter cursed child
Harry Potter cursed child
Harry Potter and the Cursed Child.
Harry Potter and the Cursed Child.
Harry Potter and the Cursed Child Split In Two | The Mary Sue
Harry Potter and the Cursed Child Split In Two | The Mary Sue

Moreover, Rowling's involvement, though extensive in the development of the story, is less prominent than in her original books. This has led some fans to question whether the Cursed Child should be considered canonical. Despite these discussions, Rowling has stated that the play is part of the Harry Potter story, further confusing the issue.

New Characters and Plotlines

The Cursed Child introduces several new characters, most notably Scorpius Hyperion malfoy, Draco Malfoy's son. His friendship with Albus Severus Potter plays a central role in the story, offering a unique perspective on the magical world.

Everyone’s Saying The Same Thing About “Cursed Child” Being Fanfic
Everyone’s Saying The Same Thing About “Cursed Child” Being Fanfic
Harry Potter Cursed Child Fanfic
Harry Potter Cursed Child Fanfic
a book cover with an image of a bird's nest and the words 10 things to know if you haven't read
a book cover with an image of a bird's nest and the words 10 things to know if you haven't read

The Salt Lake (or Time-Turner) plotline, which involves altering past events, dramatically affects the characters and world of Harry Potter. This plot device treads into uncharted territory, challenging the rules of magic and time within the series.

Differences in Style and Tone

The play's format, limited stage direction, and lack of internal monologues distinguish it from the original novels. This change in style may make it challenging for some fans to embrace it as a true continuation of the series.

The humor and dialogue in the Cursed Child often diverge from the witty, inventive style found in Rowling's books. While there are still moments of wit, the play's tone can feel less magical, leading some fans to criticize it as out of character.

the poster for harry potter and the curious child, which features an image of a bird's nest
the poster for harry potter and the curious child, which features an image of a bird's nest
harry potter ran so cursed child could trip and fall on its face
harry potter ran so cursed child could trip and fall on its face
Is Harry Potter and the Cursed Child Canon?
Is Harry Potter and the Cursed Child Canon?
Which Harry Potter and the Cursed Child character are you?
Which Harry Potter and the Cursed Child character are you?
Should I Take My Tweens to see Harry Potter and the Cursed Child? - Nourishing Tweens
Should I Take My Tweens to see Harry Potter and the Cursed Child? - Nourishing Tweens
😂😭🤣
😂😭🤣

The Impact of the Cursed Child

Despite the controversy surrounding its canonicity, "Harry Potter and the Cursed Child" has had a significant impact on the Harry Potter franchise.

The play provides a new entry point for theatergoing fans, and its success has paved the way for further Harry Potter stage productions, including "Thetenant of Dumbledore's Army." Additionally, the Cursed Child's exploration of themes like time, memory, and legacy continues the series' tradition of addressing complex themes in a relatable way.

A New Generation of Fans

The Cursed Child has introduced the Harry Potter story to a new generation of fans, who may not have experienced the original books or films.

a bird's nest with two baby birds in it on top of yellow paper
a bird's nest with two baby birds in it on top of yellow paper
Harry Potter and the cursed child
Harry Potter and the cursed child
Broadway Box Office Cools as Holiday Surge Fades, With Harry Potter and the Cursed Child Leading the Pack
Broadway Box Office Cools as Holiday Surge Fades, With Harry Potter and the Cursed Child Leading the Pack

By centering on the next generation of Hogwarts students, the play allows these new fans to connect with the magical world on their terms. Moreover, the Cursed Child's diverse cast has been praised for making the story more relatable and inclusive for a broader audience.

Expanding the Potterverse

The play's exploration of time travel and alternative realities opens up new narrative possibilities within the Harry Potter universe.

Following the Cursed Child, other works have delved into different periods of the magical world, such as "Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them" and "The Tales of Beedle the Bard." This expansion ensures that the Harry Potter series continues to evolve and captivate fans old and new.

The debate surrounding the canonicity of "Harry Potter and the Cursed Child" may never be fully resolved, but its impact on the series and its fans is undeniable. Whether it's a canonical addition or simply a love letter to dedicated fans, the play stands as a testament to the enduring power of the Harry Potter story. As the magical world continues to grow, one thing is certain: the Boy Who Lived will continue to captivate our imaginations, both on stage and off.