In the wholesale real estate arena, assignments of contracts are a common strategy employed by investors. However, one critical aspect that often leaves investors bewildered is the tax implications of assignment fees. Understanding how much tax you might pay on assignment fees is crucial for maintaining your profit margins and staying compliant with tax laws.
The taxability of assignment fees in wholesale real estate primarily hinges on how the IRS views them - as capital gains or ordinary income. This distinction significantly impacts your tax liability, making it essential to explore each scenario.
Assignment Fees as Capital Gains
When assignment fees are considered capital gains, they are taxed based on the holding period of the property under contract. Short-term capital gains (less than a year) are taxed as ordinary income, while long-term capital gains (longer than a year) enjoy preferential tax rates.
If the property was held for less than a year before the assignment, the fee is treated as short-term capital gain. In this scenario, the fee is added to your other income for the year and taxed according to your income tax bracket. For 2021, the highest bracket is 37%, applying to single filers with incomes over $523,600 and married filing jointly with incomes over $628,300.
Act of Diversification
Tax treatment can change if the IRS views your assignment as an act of diversification rather than a sale. Here, the assignment fee is considered a return of capital, not a capital gain. However, to qualify, the property must be re-invested in a similar property within 180 days.
To illustrate, suppose you're a single filer in the 24% tax bracket (incomes between $86,376 and $164,925). You assign a contract for a property you've held for eight months for a fee of $20,000. Since the property was held for less than a year, the fee is treated as short-term capital gain. Thus, you'll pay a total of $4,800 (24%) in taxes on the assignment fee.
Properties Held for More Than a Year
If the property was held for over a year before the assignment, the fee is treated as long-term capital gain. Long-term capital gains are taxed at 0%, 15%, or 20%, depending on your taxable income.
Using the previous example, if the property was held for 13 months, the assignment fee would be a long-term capital gain. Since you're in the 24% bracket, you'll pay $4,000 (20%) in taxes, assuming this is your only source of long-term capital gains.
Assignment Fees as Ordinary Income
In some instances, assignment fees are treated as ordinary income, especially when the assignment involves significant renegotiation or change in the terms of the purchase agreement. When this occurs, the fee is added to your other income and taxed at your ordinary income tax rate.
If you believe your assignment fee should be treated as ordinary income or capital gain, consulting with a tax professional or attorney can ensure the most advantageous tax treatment.
Recourse vs. Non-Recourse Loans
One factor influencing tax treatment is the type of loan backing the property under contract. In general, if you assign a contract with a non-recourse loan, the fee is considered a gain on the sale of the property. However, if the loan is recourse, the fee may be considered ordinary income.
The 'But-For' Test
A crucial determinant in the IRS's decision to tax assignment fees as ordinary income is the 'but-for' test. essentially, if the assignment would not have occurred 'but for' changes in the contract terms, the fee is likely to be treated as ordinary income.
Understanding how much tax you pay on assignment fees in wholesale real estate is complex and requires in-depth knowledge of tax laws. Seeking professional advice ensures you're maximizing your profit potential while remaining tax-compliant. Regularly review your tax strategies as tax laws change, and remember, proactive planning can save you substantially in the long run.