✦Template Printable Ideas Insights

Does Detention Still Exist After School?

By

While detention has long been a staple in schools to enforce discipline, the practice of after-school detention has evolved, or even ended, in some educational systems. Today, one might wonder: do schools still have after school detention?

Answers to this question depend largely on the school's policies, regional regulations, and cultural norms. Let's delve into the evolution of after-school detention, its current status, and alternative disciplinary methods.

The Evolution of After-School Detention

Traditionally, after-school detention served as a punishment for misbehavior, requiring students to remain at school after hours to complete assigned tasks or reflect on their actions. This practice has persisted for decades, but its form and function have shifted over time.

a group of people sitting on the floor under a table
a group of people sitting on the floor under a table
Differences in Academic Achievement in Students
Differences in Academic Achievement in Students
a blackboard with the word detention written on it and an arrow pointing up
a blackboard with the word detention written on it and an arrow pointing up

A survey by the National Center for Education Statistics reveals that in 2013-2014, around 55% of public schools had policies on after-school detention.

Still Present in Many Schools

In many schools, particularly traditional ones, after-school detention remains an effective disciplinary tool. It provides a structured environment for students to reflect on their actions and offers teachers a means to enforce rules. Some schools use it as a step before more severe consequences, such as suspension.

Wednesday Wonderings - Does Detention Work?
Wednesday Wonderings - Does Detention Work?
three children are sitting at a table with books and pencils in front of them
three children are sitting at a table with books and pencils in front of them
After School Detention Online Coloring Page
After School Detention Online Coloring Page

For instance, the United States continues to report high instances of after-school detention. According to the U.S. Department of Education, in the 2017-2018 school year, more than 3 million students received at least one out-of-school suspension, including detentions.

Decline in Progressive Educational Settings

In contrast, progressive and alternative schools often adopt restorative justice practices or positive behavior supports, which focus on rehabilitation rather than punishment. Some schools have abandoned after-school detention, seeing it as ineffective or counterproductive.

For example, California's Compton Unified School District transitioned to a restorative justice model in 2012. After seeing a significant decline in suspensions, including after-school detentions, District officials reported improved school climate and increased attendance.

Eight tips for better detentions
Eight tips for better detentions
Detention Notice - Editable Parent Letter - Middle School
Detention Notice - Editable Parent Letter - Middle School
a blue and white sign that says detention on the side of a wall
a blue and white sign that says detention on the side of a wall
there is a sign on the door that says detention
there is a sign on the door that says detention
Mother Refuses to Let Daughter Do After School Detention Due to Safety Concerns
Mother Refuses to Let Daughter Do After School Detention Due to Safety Concerns
an old black and white photo of people in a room with many children standing around
an old black and white photo of people in a room with many children standing around

Alternative Disciplinary Methods

Many schools explore alternative disciplinary methods, aiming to teach students responsibility and foster positive behavioral changes. These alternatives often fall under the umbrella of restorative justice, positive behavior supports, or social-emotional learning.

Some of these alternatives include reflection or 'think' rooms, peer mediation, and conflict resolution workshops. They aim to build a positive school culture, helping students develop self-awareness, self-management, social awareness, and relationship skills, thus reducing the need for punitive measures like after-school detention.

Restorative Justice Programs

Restorative justice practices, such as face-to-face meetings or circles, focus on repairing harm and building relationships. By addressing the needs of everyone affected by misbehavior - victims, offending students, and the school community - these programs foster empathy, accountability, and heal relationships.

Namaste: At Laveen Elementary, yoga is replacing detention
Namaste: At Laveen Elementary, yoga is replacing detention
an empty classroom with desks and chairs in front of large windows looking out onto the ocean
an empty classroom with desks and chairs in front of large windows looking out onto the ocean

A flagship restorative justice program, the International Institute for Restorative Practices (IIRP) Europe, has seen success in lowering suspension rates and improving school climate in various settings, from primary schools to youth detention facilities.

Positive Behavior Support Systems

Positive behavior support systems teach and reward prosocial behavior. They promote a safe, positive school culture by explicitly teaching behavioral expectations, acknowledging and rewarding appropriate behavior, and providing support for struggling students.

One such system, Positive Behavioral Interventions and Supports (PBIS), has shown significant decreases in office referrals, suspensions, and increases in student engagement across numerous U.S. schools.

In conclusion, while after-school detention persists in many schools, its role in discipline today is complex and evolving. Schools worldwide explore alternative methods to create safer, more supportive learning environments. The future of after-school detention likely depends on each school's unique context and commitment to positive, effective disciplinary strategies."