Are you a California tenant wondering, "Can my landlord ask about my criminal record?" You're not alone. As a responsible renter, it's crucial to understand your rights and the rights of your landlord in this matter. In California, landlords can indeed ask about your criminal past, but they must do so within certain legal boundaries.
California's Fair Housing laws protect tenants from unfair discrimination. While landlords can consider an applicant's criminal history, they must follow specific guidelines to ensure they are not discriminating unlawfully. Let's delve into the intricacies of this topic, exploring what landlords can ask, when they can ask it, and how they should handle this sensitive information.
What California Landlords Can Ask
Firstly, let's establish what information landlords can legally seek. According to California's Housing and Community Development Department, landlords can request a criminal history summary from the California Department of Justice and the FBI.
They can also ask applicants to provide a Consumer Reporting Agency (CRA) report. These agencies compile information on an applicant's credit history, rental history, and, yes, criminal record. However, landlords must follow explicit procedures when asking for this information.
Allowable Questions
Landlords can ask if you have any criminal convictions that could impact your ability to live peacefully in their property. However, they should phrase their questions carefully. They cannot ask if you have ever been arrested, as arrests do not equate to convictions. Nor can they ask about minor offenses or infractions that do not relate to your suitability as a tenant.
They can, however, ask about felony convictions, especially if they are recent or involve violent or drug-related offenses. They may also inquire about misdemeanors, depending on their nature and the recency of the conviction.
International and Out-of-State Records
Landlords can ask about convictions that occurred outside of California. They can also request information from international databases, depending on what is legally accessible. However, they must ensure that the information they gather and use aligns with local, state, and federal laws.
For instance, some jurisdictions prohibit discrimination based on arrests, not just convictions. Moreover, some states and cities have passed their own "Fair Chance Housing" ordinances, which restrict what landlords can ask and how they can use criminal record information. Landlords must be aware of these local laws, especially if they operate in multiple jurisdictions.
When and How Landlords Can Ask
Landlords cannot ask about your criminal record before extending a conditional lease offer. If they refuse to rent to you based solely on your criminal history before this point, they could be violating Fair Housing laws.
However, once they extend a conditional offer, landlords can ask for a criminal background check. They must, though, notify you in writing that they plan to obtain this information. They should also provide you with an opportunity to explain and discuss any criminal history that may appear on the report.
Background Check Procedures
When conducting a background check, landlords must follow strict procedures. They must use a CRA that complies with the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA). They must also get your written permission before running the check. If they decide not to rent to you based on the results, they must notify you in writing. This notification should include the name, address, and phone number of the CRA that provided the report.
Moreover, they must maintain the confidentiality of your criminal record information. They should store this information securely and destroy it once they no longer need it for a legitimate business purpose.
Consideration of Criminal History
When considering your criminal history, landlords must avoid blanket disqualifications. They should assess each application on a case-by-case basis, considering factors such as the type and severity of the offense, its date, and your rehabilitation efforts. They must also be prepared to justify any decision to refuse housing based on criminal history.
Ultimately, landlords should strive for fairness and consistency. They should treat all applicants equally, regardless of their criminal histories. They should also document their decision-making process in case of a Fair Housing complaint to demonstrate they acted lawfully and fairly.