✦Template Printable Ideas Insights

Can Boys Join Girl Scouts? The Nuanced Answer

By

In recent years, there's been a growing discussion about inclusive scouting, including the question, "Can a boy join Girl Scouts?" This topic has gained traction as traditional gender roles in youth organizations start to evolve. Traditionally, Girl Scouts was for girls and Boy Scouts for boys, but with the establishment of Scouts BSA in 2019, even that division has started to blur.

The short answer is that typically, boys cannot join Girl Scouts, and girls cannot join Boy Scouts, due to the defined genders in their charters. However, things aren't as straightforward as they once were. The Boy Scouts of America (BSA), for instance, now offers a Scout program for girls, and the Girl Scouts of the USA (GSUSA) offers a variety of Programs for boys through their Destination Program.

Historical Context of Gender Segregation

Scouting organizations were founded with gender segregation as a norm. The Boy Scouts of America (BSA) was founded in 1910 for boys, while the Girl Guides of America (now Girl Scouts of the USA) was founded in 1912, primarily for girls. This segregation persisted for most of the 20th century.

The Trouble With Girls in Boy Scouts
The Trouble With Girls in Boy Scouts
the tweet is being used to describe what girl scouts are doing on twitter
the tweet is being used to describe what girl scouts are doing on twitter
a group of young women standing next to each other
a group of young women standing next to each other

However, by the end of the century, societal norms and expectations around gender roles began to shift, as did the landscape of youth development organizations.

Court Rulings and Changing Laws

A notable legal precedent set in 2018 in California influenced these changes. A girl, comparisons, filed a complaint with the California Department of Fair Employment and Housing, stating that her exclusion from the local BSA troop was gender discrimination. The court ruled in her favor, stating she could join a previously all-boys' troop.

Are Boy Scouts Better Than Girl Scouts? - Leadership Girl
Are Boy Scouts Better Than Girl Scouts? - Leadership Girl
10 Things You Know If You're a Girl in Boy Scouts
10 Things You Know If You're a Girl in Boy Scouts
two people sitting at a table with papers
two people sitting at a table with papers

This ruling, although not applicable nationwide, set a significant precedent for future inclusivity discussions in scouting organizations.

National Organizations' Responses

In response to these changes, the BSA announced in 2017 that they would start accepting female members. This policy change allowed girls to join BSA units, set the stage for a new program aimed at girls, Scouts BSA, launched in 2019.

Meanwhile, the GSUSA, in a statement, affirmed its commitment to serving and including all girls, regardless of gender identity, noting that they welcomed transgender girls in their programs.

Scouts google form
Scouts google form
Girls can now be Boy Scouts for the first time
Girls can now be Boy Scouts for the first time
Are Boy Scouts Better Than Girl Scouts? - Leadership Girl
Are Boy Scouts Better Than Girl Scouts? - Leadership Girl
Boy Scouts and Girl Scouts- Everything You Need to Know
Boy Scouts and Girl Scouts- Everything You Need to Know
What 1 Mom's Boy Scout Son Said About Girls Being Able to Join His Troop
What 1 Mom's Boy Scout Son Said About Girls Being Able to Join His Troop
Boy Scouts and Girl Scouts Suspend Meetings, But Recommend Virtual Adventure
Boy Scouts and Girl Scouts Suspend Meetings, But Recommend Virtual Adventure

Inclusive Programs for Both Genders

Both organizations have taken steps to create more inclusive programs. Still, the question of whether a boy can join Girl Scouts directly remains less clear-cut.

One notable provision is the GSUSA's Destination Program. This program allows boys and girls to participate in traditional Girl Scout meetings and activities through Stonewall, Destin_CLGBTC (for boys), and Journeys (for girls).

Scouts BSA and Venturing Scouts

For boys interested in joining a co-ed scouting organization, Scouts BSA offers a robust program. It includes Cub Scouts for boys and girls aged 5-10, Scouts BSA for boys and girls aged 11-17, and a Venturing program for young men and women aged 14-20.

a bald man sitting in a chair with his hands out and the caption says, equality
a bald man sitting in a chair with his hands out and the caption says, equality
Girls Scouts vs. Boy Scouts
Girls Scouts vs. Boy Scouts
20+ Tips for Brand New Girl Scout Leaders - Whether you fell into being a Leader, or have been dreaming about it for years, check out these tips from someone who just finished her first year. How To Organize Troop Meetings, Girl Scout Grade Levels, First Girl Scout Meeting Ideas, Girl Scout Leader Day, Girl Scout Troop Meeting Ideas, Girl Scout Troop Meeting, Scout Troop Leadership Tips, Girl Scout Levels By Grade, Troop Leading Procedures
20+ Tips for Brand New Girl Scout Leaders - Whether you fell into being a Leader, or have been dreaming about it for years, check out these tips from someone who just finished her first year. How To Organize Troop Meetings, Girl Scout Grade Levels, First Girl Scout Meeting Ideas, Girl Scout Leader Day, Girl Scout Troop Meeting Ideas, Girl Scout Troop Meeting, Scout Troop Leadership Tips, Girl Scout Levels By Grade, Troop Leading Procedures

In these programs, boys and girls work together, learning and earning badges side by side, fostering a more inclusive scouting experience.

In conclusion, while the simple answer to 'can a boy join Girl Scouts' is typically 'no,' the answers can become more complex due to inclusive programs and policies. The shift towards more inclusive scouting models signals a broader evolution in youth development programs, opening new avenues for boys and girls to learn and grow together."